Week 7 news

February 26, 2020


The city of Seoul is planning on having every public building and 1 million homes run on solar power by 2022. The city will educate and subsidize the cost of the solar panels for the 840,000 citizens who still need them. The city center has already seen a solar transformation with lights and trash cans. South Korea is also looking to transition 30% of there energy needs to hydrogen by 2040.

News article

February 26, 2020


The state of Washington has banned new permits to commercially bottle water that is retroactive back to January 1st, 2019.

This bill prevents Crystal Geyser, a company that has been in trouble in California for delivering arsenic water to treatment plants and not disclosing that information, from opening a bottling plant in southwest Washington

Week 7 Environmental News

February 26, 2020

Laboratory-evolved bacteria switch to consuming carbon dioxide for growth from Science Daily


Yes, this article is almost as cool as the title claims. It talks about the process some scientists went through to convince gut bacteria to consume CO2 instead of the organic stuff it usually does. About a third of it is background info, and another third is about how excited the scientists were and how unexpected and amazing the discovery is for science the future of CO2 reduction. This process is still in the very early stages of development, for example, the bacteria still emit more CO2 than they absorb, but it’s a step in the right direction and exciting things may still come of it.

Reading Week 7: Nature- Western Attitudes since ancient times

February 26, 2020

p 146 “Every culture projects its values onto nature and then holds them up as nature’s own authority, deploying this apparently unimpeachable and independent source of authority to justify its vision of society and the world.”

This quote really struck me because it’s so true. That section of the book talks about people justifying slavery, the feudal system, and unbridled capitalism through the lens that those things happen in nature so it’s fine if we do them. I can come up with other examples besides the ones in the book too. Sexism for one. Also the idea that we can do whatever we want because animals that have less self control than us seem to do whatever they want even though most of the time they’re just doing what they need to to survive.

Also men, especially men from the past, personify nature as a woman they can conquer, like Abbey, the author of Desert Solitarie did.

Just because nature seems savage and whatever else you think it is doesn’t give you the right to caricature what you think is going on.

On the plus side, nature can be a symbol of empowerment. For example, animals such as bees, elephants, and seahorses are representations of the women’s movement because of the role females play in those animals’ dynamics.


In the 1940s, Nazis went so far as to relocate rural jews to inner city ghettos to perpetuate the stereo type that jews were unnatural because they lived in the unnatural cities.

This section jumped out at me because that’s very much not the view of cities we have today. According to CNBC, 55% of the world’s population lives in cities, so it makes sense that this perception has changed from the 1940s. My first thought was that it was really strange for the rich people who built up the cities to call them unnatural but then I remembered that a lot of the elite members of society then and now build their megamansions in the country so they don’t have to deal with people. It makes sense. But also wouldn’t it be more impressive to buy out expansive apartment complexes and live there than to bully farmer Joe until he caves and sells all his land at a horrible price? Why is it that access to nature is a privilege now instead of a right? Should it be a right?

p 186

nature has always been indomitable

I started reading this section awaiting the end of that thought. Nature has always been indomitable, but now it is not. The classic eco-guilt lecture it seems every nature documentary and book about the environment is so eager to hurl at the unsuspecting audience, but that amazingly didn’t happen here. It was incredibly refreshing to not have to wade through that for the thousandth time. And the replacement ideas presented instead were ones of hope!

It also gave some good points about nature’s potential to recover from human mistakes. I feel like humans always focus on the bad example, such as the case of Easter Island. I have spent probably a week’s worth of my life reading about and watching documentaries and studying Easter Island because it’s such an excellent example of when things go wrong and don’t get better. It used to be a thriving tropical forest, and now it can barely support grass and a handful of carefully cultivated palm trees. This is entirely due to human deforestation. People cut down the native trees to grow palms and after the trees were cut down the rain washed away the nutrients leading to the downfall of the people there. Ecologists are obsessed with this. They claim this island is a potential microcosm of our entire planet when we eventually fail to stop global warming before the appropriate deadline. But what actually are the chances that we will push the entire planet past the point of no return assuming there even is one? I don’t know.

Environmental news

February 26, 2020


More than 155 people died from heat-related causes in the Phoenix area last year, a new record in a place where the number of such deaths has been on the rise. The mayor deemed is a public health crisis.

As temperatures are getting higher in certain areas, more people are dying. Education is important in the sense that people need to stay hydrated and cool as much as they can when temperatures skyrocket to 115 degrees Fahrenheit.

Coates 6-9

February 26, 2020

“The role of the countryside as an amenity for wealthy urbanites, originally enshrined in the roman villa rusticate, had been in retreat during the later Middle Ages, when Norman hunting reserves were eroded by economic pressures…but the new parks, besides being larger than their predecessors, were more than just hunting grounds.”

Image result for norman hunting reserves
medieval hunting

“Modern environmentalism has been conditioned by a range of dangers to land, air, seas and inland waters that are largely unique to the period since the Second World War.”

“Nevertheless, late 20th century attitudes to nature, particularly the valorization of its wilder aspects and conceptions of hallowed natural systems under threat, remain essentially shaped by two intellectual developments from the 18th and 19th centuries respectively that questioned the ideology of industrial capitalism and sometimes modernity itself: romanticism and the emergence of ecological science via evolutionary theory.”

Image result for romanticism art
romanticism art

“Evolutionary theory most obvious consequences, however, were for orthodox christianity. Evolution taught that the giant tortoises and iguanas of the Galapagos Islands off the coast of Ecuador had migrated there instead of being installed by a divine creator: The idea of nature as the outcome of historical forces replaced that of the one-off creation…Darwin was hardly spoiling for a fight with christianity…natural law and natural selection in fact left God’s role in the origins of life open.”

“The idea of nature to which one comes under the domination of private property and of money is the actual contempt, the practical degradation of nature…in this sense, Thomas Münzer [a 16th century anabaptist dissident and leader of peasent revolt] declares it intolerable ‘that all creates have been made into property, the fish in the water, the birds in the air, the plants on the earth – the creators, too, must be free’ .” – Marx

Image result for karl marx
Karl Marx

“Since plastic trees are cheaper to make and easier to maintain, more durable, and can be made more readily available than the scarce trees and places we currently treasure, why can’t we be trained to enjoy their proxies as much as the real thing? After all, if a forged painting provides the same quality of aesthetic experience as the authentic article, why should this bother us?”

Coates 6-9 reading

February 26, 2020

Pg124 “To the homesteader staking a claim to a patch of American earth and converting it from nature to property through labor, the impoundment of public space meant freedom and autonomy. By contrast, the displaced American Indian who saw the prairie sod being busted by blundering plough by these refugees from the old country’s blundering plough might easily have thought that Clare’s poem was written as an elegy for them and for American nature newly placed in bondage.”

Pg127 “The belief that people are free by nature but enslaved by man inspired a range of causes from medieval peasant revolt to the eighteenth-century anti-slavery movement.”

Pg157 “Their goal is to redeem the city by reconceptualizing ‘nature’ and ‘the environment’ as peoples ordinary daily living, working, and playing spaces.”

Pg164 “Women were the main consumers of bird products.”

Pg171 “Shoving humanity off its pedestal may sound exhilarating to those who believe that a fundamental philosophical shift is necessary to save the planet.”

Pg180 “He argues ingeniously, for instance, that tunny fish have a mathematical grasp because they swim in geometric patterns, and that elephants engage in the equivalent of a religious exercise after washing at dawn, standing in devotional pose at regular intervals during the day hereafter.”

puffer fish mating ritual

Week 7: Reading Notes, Comments

February 25, 2020

Nature: Notes, Comments (Ch. 6-9)

P111. “We are also gradually recognizing that the landscapes of the American west, which nineteenth-century white adventurers, nature writers, and national park promoters hailed as exemplars of pristine and unadorned nature, were actually created by Euro-American incursion and reconceptualization.” The American West, Texas, New Mexico, Nevada, Wyoming, were shaped as a result of digging and drilling and the repurposing of land and space in the West. The vast, harsh desert and mountain ranges were in part formed and altered by human incursion and are not the sole product of the natural world. As a result, does this idea of human influence forming nature change the concept of nature itself? Does nature have to be void of human influence to be “nature”?

Image result for the american west

P145. “The Nazi experience is important to them (scholars) because it highlights the difficulties of trying to situate green thought and practice neatly within an ideological spectrum running from bright red to vivid blue (and brown).” Stemming from the idea that environmentalism comes in many shades of colors and is hard to identify, the Nazi perspective is valuable.

P146. “Every culture projects its values onto nature and then holds them up as nature’s own authority” This relates to previous concepts of the law’s of nature and whether or not they change/vary depending on interpretive definitions of nature. Should aspects and laws of nature be dependent on culture/location? I think laws of nature should be uniform concepts.

P166. “In the late nineteenth century, Kulturpessimismus (cultural pessimism) boosted the manufacture of a mythological past rooted in nature.” It is interesting to see how groups of people identity with nature throughout history.

P174. “The grave announcement of Lake Erie’s ‘death’ through eutrophication (oxygen starvation) catalyzed American public awareness of an ecological crisis in the 1960’s.” Really interesting that one of the initial ecological catastrophes was here in Ohio..

Here is a link regarding the history and future of the ecological disaster of the Great Lakes freshwater system https://thevarsity.ca/2019/05/11/saving-the-great-lakes-from-ecological-disaster/

Image result for Eutrophication of lake erie
Eutrophication of Lake Erie (2017)

P179. “If ‘they’ (animals) are shown to be more like ‘us’ – not through religiosity or sentimentality but on purely intellectual grounds – then biocentric ecophilosophers might have an easier job persuading other people to include ‘them’ and their interests with our ethical circle.” Essentially, what is the nature of animals? Are they intellectual like us and as a result, worth protecting? Should this be a concern for everyone?

Week 7: Environmental News

February 25, 2020

They’re a scientific marvel- World’s first in vitro cheetah cubs born at Ohio zoo

https://www.They’re a ‘scientific marvel’: World’s first in vitro cheetah cubs born at Ohio zoousatoday.com/story/news/nation/2020/02/24/vitro-cheetah-cubs-worlds-first-born-columbus-zoo/4856829002/

Image result for in vitro fertilization in cheetahs
Female cheetah- Izzy- and her in vitro offspring at the Columbus Zoo

The first cheetah cubs ever conceived through in vitro fertilization were born last Monday at the Columbus Zoo and Aquarium. The two cubs, a male and a female, were born to a first-time mother, Izzy, at the Columbus Zoo. However, she is not their biological mother. Their mother is Kibibi, a 6-and-a-half-year-old cheetah also located at the Columbus Zoo. Kibibi has never reproduced and is too old to reproduce naturally now, and researchers were concerned about losing important genes in the species gene pool. As a result, in vitro fertilization was done.

Biologists from the Smithsonian Conservation Biology Institute in Virginia fertilized the eggs obtained from Kibibi in a laboratory. The eggs were incubated, and embryos were created, which they then successfully implanted into Izzy.

Image result for in vitro fertilization steps in animals
Example of the process of IVF in animals

This scientific development is a huge milestone, as it helps maintain genetic diversity, which ultimately keeps offspring healthy. In vitro fertilization has only been attempted 3 times in cheetahs and has already been successful. This plan to maintain a diverse genetic population could help combat a decline in genetic diversity in the future as a result of the decreasing population of cheetahs in the wild. Cheetahs are currently considered vulnerable, with only about 7,500 animals left in the wild, and they only inhabit approximately 10% of their native historic habitat in Africa. This breakthrough discovery at the Columbus Zoo helps ensure the potential of survival of this species the wild.

Project Proposal

February 23, 2020

Covered Bike Shelters with Planted Roof

Project Participant(s): Lauren Kulazenka and collaborating with Janelle Valdinger

Description & overview of project: 

This project’s aim is to install green architecture on campus, starting with bike shelters that have planted roofs.  Currently, bike racks on campus do not have any protection, so bikes that are parked at them are left exposed to the elements, wearing the bike down faster.  Covering the bikes will prevent this from happening and encourage student to use bike to get to class instead of driving and parking in the overcrowded parking lots on campus. These covered racks have the added benefit of decreasing rain runoff (Nardin) and CO2 (Li) in the areas that they are in.

In areas that already have bike racks with proper clearance, they can easily be replaced with the bike shelters. For those that do not, and area to put the shelter will need to be made.  In order to make these shelters and eco friendly as possible, the shelters that will need to have a spot created can use pervious pavers instead of concrete.  The pervious pavers will direct water down into the ground instead of drains, decreasing rain runoff and increasing water going to the underground aquifer (Blundell).  The pervious pavers are also not as permanent as a concrete slab is, so if the rack needs to be moved for some reason, the ground can easily be replanted and put back to normal.

The plants on top of the bike racks, soak up rainwater, stopping rainwater runoff (Nardin), this paired with the racks that have pervious pavers should reduce runoff to almost zero.  Since these racks will be going into placed that have been developed, they will allow more plants to exist in these areas allowing for more CO2 to be captured and for more oxygen to be produced (Li).  The type of plants going on the top of the racks will be sedum, which is a succulent.  Being a succulent, they do not need much upkeep as they are drought resistant and can tolerate full sun.  they are also a type of groundcover plant and because of this they prevent undesired plants from growing.

As of right now, most of the work has been done. There is a tentative price for how much the racks will cost and the size of the racks has been provided.  Funding is the current issue and Janelle and I are working on finding a source that does not need to go through the Universities method of assigning funding.  I need to take a walk around campus and find suitable sites for the racks.  They need to have proper sidewalk clearance as well as building clearance.  They will also need to be in areas that provide adequate sun, so for taller building they may need to be located on the Southern or Eastern sides.  I also need to get an estimate for how much the pervious pavers will cost and the cost of installation.  Fortunately, this will only need to be done for some of the bike racks.

Outline of project:

  • What the racks are
    • Benefits of racks
      • Bike Protection
      • Rainwater runoff
      • CO2 and oxygen
  • Location of racks
    • Academic campus
    • Residential campus
  • Which racks have pervious pavers
  • Cost and funding
  • Approval

Annotated bibliography

  • Li, J., Wai, O., Li, Y., Zhan, J., Ho, Y., Li, J., & Lam, E. (2010). Effect of green roof on ambient CO2 concentration. Building and Environment, 45(12), 2644-2651.

This paper looks at the effect of a green roof on the surrounding CO2 concentration in order to assess the benefit of urban greening.

  • Nardini, A., Andri, S., & Crasso, M. (2012). Influence of substrate depth and vegetation type on temperature and water runoff mitigation by extensive green roofs: shrubs versus 16 herbaceous plants. Urban Ecosystems, 15(3), 697-708.

Study shows that green roofs have the ability to decrease rain runoff from buildings.

  • Women’s Sports & Fitness, vol. 7, no. 2, Mar. 1985, p. 24. EBSCOhost, search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=f5h&AN=8500001914&site=ehost-live.

Paper describes the health benefits of bicycling.

  • Blundell, Peter. “Pervious Pavers Provide New Solution for Stormwater Management.” WaterWorld, vol. 27, no. 11, Nov. 2011, p. 36. EBSCOhost, search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=f5h&AN=67442944&site=ehost-live.

Provides usefulness of flow rate and usefulness of the pervious pavers and how they have a wide range of applications.

  • Vasl, A., et al. ” Sedum —Annual plant interactions on green roofs: Facilitation, competition and exclusion.” Ecological Engineering, vol. 108, 2017, pp. 318-329. OhioLINK Electronic Journal Center, doi:10.1016/J.ECOLENG.2017.07.034.

Provides information about why sedum is used on green roofs.  Study in paper worked with adding in other plants to optimize growth of both plants.

  • Kitheka, Bernard. “INVENTORY OF STORMWATER MANAGEMENT PRACTICES IN THE CITY OF OXFORD, OHIO.” Electronic Thesis or Dissertation. Miami University, 2010. OhioLINK Electronic Theses and Dissertations Center. 23 Feb 2020.

A city with a similar climate as Delaware uses these pervious pavers on a large scale (parking lot). Also provides a cost benefit analysis compared to using concrete or asphalt as well as pollution reduction analysis.

Proposal written by OSU students to install a planted bike rack at OSU. Provides information about the racks and the benefits of them.

  • Janelle Valdinger

Collaborating with me on this project, she has been working on a similar project and knows who to talk to about funding and getting approval.

  • Wanner Metalworks

Company that made the covered shelters in Columbus and gave us an estimated cost.  Also provided schematics of the shelters and options for rack styles.

  • OWU B & G

Providing approval for the bike shelter areas once they are approved.